Moronic Fun with Nya-tan and Etotama

If you had told me at the beginning of the season that I would pick up this CG-heavy, cutesy battle girls show, I would’ve laughed you off of my screen. I’ve come a long way from my earlier disdain for CG, thanks in large part to gems like Sidonia no Kishi and Sanzoku no Musume Ronja, and the application to Etotama remains with the battle sequences, leaving most everything else to 2D. My true aversion to this show came mainly from the harem set up and bawdy interactions, which oddly enough have now faded into the background of my viewing experience. Etotama slowly but steadily charmed me with its zodiac members and Nya-tan’s well-meaning but usually chaotic actions, the self-aware comedy, and very prettily executed battles.

“The anime’s story revolves around Nyaa-tan, the cat of Chinese astrology who wants to become a member of the Chinese zodiac. Nyaa-tan is simple and suffers from memory loss, and she tries various foolish ways to become a member. She meets Takeru Amato, a high school student who lives alone in Akihabara, and becomes a freeloader at his house. Little by little, she gets closer to her goal.” – ANN

The only other show that I’ve watched with obvious connections to the Chinese Zodiac was Fruits Basket, which is a different animal altogether from Etotama. The two both featured a solid set of the twelve original members, as well as the outsider Cat who remains apart yet separate from family affairs. Nya-tan’s depiction of the cat isn’t a favorable one; she’s reckless and selfish, repeatedly causing havoc to herself and those around her. She wants in as an official member of the zodiac, but has no memories of her past lives or any other desires. Her wish for the title of Eto-shin is her sole remaining remembrance. For most of what we and Takeru have seen, Nya-tan has no place among the twelve. There’s a comical moment where Shima-tan asks her to recall why she clings to Takeru, and in her defensive retort, she realizes that she doesn’t actually have that many memories endearing the two to each other. Yet there’s something about who she was and maybe a bit of who she is now that keeps her supporters rallying to help her win a spot. Nya-tan straddles the lines of annoyance and affection, anger and humor, and Eto-musume and Eto-shin.

Very forced at the beginning, the comedy has steadily warmed up with the recent episodes. The jokes are slapstick and self-aware, frequently breaking the 4th wall. The Eto-musume regularly refer to us, the viewer, and to their roles as characters in a show. It’s not very often that I like this break between story and audience, but Etotama does it so regularly and naturally that I end up rolling with the punches and feeling closer to our Eto-musume. They invade the viewers’ homes as easily as they do Takeru’s house. The different zodiac animals also represent their signs in obvious ways, such as the Year of the Tiger (me, me, me!) being one of the strongest combatants, as well as a fighting instructor for Nya-tan. Then there are the two carefree, seemingly dumb monkey and dog representatives, who overlap in character archetype and don’t care a whit about it.

The series has two main settings: the human world, and the ETM12 arena of the Eto-musume. The two are distinct in a number of ways, the most apparent being visually, with the use of “Pretty Mode” via CG. Our normal-sized 2D girls are miniaturized into even cuter versions of themselves. Everything from their design to the background and the animation are shiny and smooth–this is one of the most appropriate uses I’ve seen recently with such full execution. The close-ups seem to be more shaded so not only the backgrounds, but also the up-close fights, look fantastic. A similar use can be found with this season’s Show by Rock!! The glitzier template also goes well with the notion that this is a televised event; the moment a match begins, personal screens pop up for all the other passive participants to view. Just as we are watching them, they are watching their peers.

I didn’t enter in on this series with any expectations, and wouldn’t laud it as the best of the season. But! It’s been a fun and moronic ride to date and I’m committed now to seeing Nya-tan’s memories re-surface in time for her face-off with Chu-tan. Let me know if you’re watching this show and what you’ve thought so far!


7 thoughts on “Moronic Fun with Nya-tan and Etotama

  1. And again you write about a show that I find more enjoyable than expected. This one has handled the “Way Too Many Characters” issue pretty well, although there are a couple characters I could do without (everyone probably has this, and they’re different characters, mine are the dog and monkey pair, and I wish they’d do more with the rooster, but they get out of anything with her with the 3-steps-and-forget gag).

    I really like that they’ve worked the CG in as a “Different but not by much” thing. The characters are undoubtedly the same in Pretty Mode, and I always like the anime texture CG, especially done this well. I also want to point out that I just love Chu-tan’s character design. The rat ears sticking out of the hair just look terrific in both modes, and the severity of the purple jumpsuit is great. I really hope they advance the “Chu-tan’s grudge against Nya-tan” story soon.

    And as far as the CG and the textures, I like this so much better than Show By Rock’s pixarblob texturing. To me, that’s an off-the-shelf cop-out, intentionally art-shifting to get out of the uncanny valley. But that doesn’t do anything to advance the state-of-the-art of CG animation, unlike what I see in Etotama’s Pretty Mode, or in shows like Karen Senki or Arpeggio of Blue Steel, where the full CG of the show allowed seamless battle scenes. The price paid is the non-battle scenes, where the characters were sometimes stiff or a little wonky. Unfortunately, Sidonia no Kishi goes the other way and says “We don’t really care what our character animation looks like…”

    Liked by 1 person

    • I actually dropped Show by Rock!! after the first episode, and almost did the same with Etotama. I found myself unexpectedly caught up on shows one week and on a whim returned to it and ended up wanting to catch up. 🙂

      It’s interesting you bring up the other CG shows, particularly Sidonia since I agree for the most past with you on the character art. The huge exception with the sequel this season is Tusumugi, who I’ve found surprisingly well animated and characterized in her alien form. She’s more expressive than a majority of the humans on Sidonia! That might be easier with non-human forms like hers since we don’t have a familiarity with how the expressions should look, but I’m still pleased with the result.

      The really had better elaborate on Chu-tan and Nya-tan’s history after referencing it so many times. If they don’t, that’ll be my biggest gripe about the series! I also love Chu-tan’s character design, with her darker, fiercer face and huge rat ears. Her look is completely opposite of anything I would’ve imagined for Year of the Rat. I probably would’ve gone either the cute route or the shady-looking one.


  2. I loveeeeeee this series! It has plenty of laughs and interesting characters and yes as far as CG goes this one is top notch even thou I like the CG in Show By Rock even if it doesn’t hold up against Eto-Tama.


    • Great to see another fan for this show! I particularly loved the art of the most recent episode where they have the Manager Cup as a race. All the ridiculous crashes of the Eto-shin as they fail out of the race are perfectly animated.

      Liked by 1 person

Let's talk:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s